Reston Spring

Reston Spring
Reston Spring

Monday, March 24, 2014

Editorial: The Post’s View: The Silver Line’s long, hard slog, Washington Post, March 23, 2014

In what appears to be a more circumspect and far more optimistic version of what we wrote on Friday, the Washington Post Editorial Board today laments the sorry state of affairs in the completion of Phase 1 of the Silver Line.  Here is how the Post begins:
THERE WERE two significant pieces of news last month about Metro’s Silver Line extension to Dulles International Airport, one of the nation’s biggest infrastructure projects, and together they could give Northern Virginia commuters whiplash.
First came the good news: The project’s $2.7 billion second phase — 12 miles of rail running from Reston to the airport and into Loudoun County — is likely to receive almost $1.9 billion in federal loans on highly favorable terms, a critical component of the hoped-for financing for a project that broke ground last year.

Then came the bad news: Completion of the project’s $2.9 billion first phase, 11 miles of rail from East Falls Church to Reston, would be delayed. Again. . .
Near the end of the editorial, the Post goes out on a fact-free, rose-colored limb (to mix our metaphors):
Like all soap operas, this one will end — with passengers boarding Silver Line trains no later than June, we hope. That’s months later than officials had expected even a year ago, and it will cost Metro millions of dollars in lost revenue.
First, let's acknowledge a straightforward accounting error in the Post's assessment of "lost revenue":  While WMATA forecasts the Silver Line will generate about $2 million per month once it is in operation, the Post repeatedly has ignored the fact that Metrorail's operating costs exceed revenues by about half--or about $1 million per month for a new Silver LIne if WMATA's revenue forecast is accurate.  So, for every month the Silver Line is in operation, Metro will--in fact--lose about one million dollars.  And, yes, the taxpayers of the WMATA jurisdictions will be making up the difference as they have for decades.  Failure to acknowledge this important financial fact reflects badly on the Post and its editorial.

More importantly, the "hope" expressed here that passengers will be riding the Silver Line "no later June" is absurd to  the point of being dangerous in setting not just unrealistic, but impossible, expectations for the beginning of Silver Line revenue operations.  First, as the Post observes, MWAA and DTP can't even agree on what needs to be done--and who needs to pay for it.  Little, if any, work has been done in the month since the Silver Line failed to meet MWAA's (& WMATA's) standards for "substantial completion."  DTP says they don't even know what needs to be done.  Second, that work will takes a number of weeks, if not months, to complete--including the speaker replacement, repairing the ATC system (again--or still), and fixing whatever the track gage problem is.  Then, third, when the line achieves "substantial completion,"  WMATA has another 90 days to test the line itself and train its operators.  Given the dubious work on the project to date, we would expect WMATA to be especially diligent in its testing and training, using just about all the 90 days it has at its disposal.

We believe that Hunter Mill Supervisor Cathy Hudgins' assessment that the line should be done by late summer or she will be "very disappointed" is probably more realistic.  And we certainly believe it is possible that the start of revenue operations will be postponed until 2015 given the sorry state of relations between MWAA and DTP in trying to bring the project up to acceptable standards. 

And, to reiterate, we want the Silver Line completed and operational as soon as it is safe to do so.  We also do not want any of the entities financing this $3 billion project--especially Dulles Toll Road users--to be socked with extra charges because of the inept handling of the construction and management of this important transportation infrastructure. 

Friday, March 21, 2014

So where is our Silver Line?

Terry Maynard

Things were looking promising last summer for opening the Silver Line.  We might actually have Metrorail service in Reston by the end of 2013 as promised repeatedly since the project began. 

A sign of the times.  (RestonNow)
Then the project timeline derailed, so to speak.

The start of Silver Line operations is now three months overdue and no one involved with the line’s construction is willing even to speculate when service will begin.  Press reports say that start-up has been delayed “indefinitely.”  Supervisor Hudgins has said she would be “very disappointed” if operations were not begun by the end of summer.  Yet, there is the distinct possibility that the Silver Line won’t open to Reston until 2015—more than a year late.  How many millions of dollars over budget and who will pay those sums remain huge unknowns despite contract terms putting cost overruns on the contractor and the project manager, MWAA. 

We first got a hint of significant construction schedule issues to come when two test trains knocked handrails and emergency shutoff switches, reportedly installed in the wrong place, off the wall of the rail tunnel in late 2012.  How does a competent contractor on a multi-billion dollar project put handrails and switches in the wrong place?  Nonetheless, assurances were given that there was nothing wrong with the tunnel even though an inch of settling in the tunnel floor had been reported a year before these incidents.

And press reports kept dribbling out last spring that there were problems with the line’s Automatic Train Control (ATC) system, including unauthorized changes in the design by its builder, Alstom Signaling.  The ATC system controls train movement and ensures proper spacing between trains.  The failure of the ATC system on Metro’s Red Line killed nine people and injured dozens more in 2009 when one Red Line train plowed into another.    Neither MWAA nor the contractor would confirm the ATC problems. 

Fatal Metrorail Red Line accident, 2009.  (Washington Post)
In May, MWAA officials were saying the project was on schedule to open in December.  The builder’s project executive director said it was 98% complete.  In June, MWAA CEO Jack Potter even said the project would be ready to turn over to WMATA on September 9, allowing WMATA’s 90-day test and training period before opening in December—on schedule.   

Then, July 17, the schedule lurched.  MWAA announced “that the expected substantial completion of Phase 1 of the Metrorail Silver Line project would be delayed by approximately eight weeks.”  Neither MWAA nor the contractor would say what caused the delay.  At the outside, that meant the project would be ready for turnover to WMATA—“substantially complete”—by the end of October or early November.

October and November passed without “substantial completion” or an explanation.

MWAA finally confirmed in a December 2, 2013, press release that continuing failures in updates to the ATC software would cause further completion delays.  No other problems were identified and no date for completion was set.

Maybe early 2014.

At first, some good news.  In early February, the contractor declared that work on the project was “substantially complete.”  MWAA had 15 days to review the contractor’s work and certify that it was satisfied that it could turn the project over to WMATA.  WMATA would then have a 90-day period of final testing and training of train operators before beginning service to Reston.   
But that didn’t happen.  In a February 24 press release, MWAA and WMATA “determined the contractor has not yet met the contract requirements for substantial completion.”  In fact, the contractor failed to meet contract requirements in seven of the 12 areas of review.   Some were nuisance issues, but the ATC continued to have “performance issues” and MWAA noted a“(f)ailure to fully correct defects that impact operations, including track gage problems.”  What?  They couldn’t lay the tracks right?

Yet, now, a month later, nothing has been done. 

And the atmosphere turned stormy this week.  Threats of multi-million dollar fines are in the air if the project is not “substantially complete” by the April 9 contract deadline.  The lead contractor blames MWAA, saying, “MWAA has yet to specify what it believes needs to be done before we can re-submit the substantial completion package.”  MWAA says it has been meeting several times daily with the contractor to work out the issues.   The contractor has also hinted that the deadline—and the fines that would follow—may be negotiable, apparently looking for a plea bargain deal.  On the other hand, former Congressman Tom Davis, now an MWAA Board member and Chairman of its Dulles Corridor Committee, called the situation “a soap opera” and is threatening a lawsuit  for liquidated damages if the contractor does not meet the deadline.

These interactions are rapidly turning away from “good faith” discussions among engineers and technicians solving construction problems.  They are becoming a standoff between accountants and attorneys for the two sides who are more interested in evading responsibility for failures and added costs than getting the job done.  They certainly aren’t driven by meeting a budget or a schedule.  Most importantly, they do not appear to have even a hint of the broader public interest in mind.

Reston wants its Silver Line rail line service now, even though it will be impossible for service to begin in the first half of the year. 

And we don’t want to pay for the shortcomings of either or both of the parties to this growing construction delays. 

It is past time for our elected leaders, county, state, and federal, to press both MWAA and Bechtel, reminding them whose money they are spending and whose rail service they are supposed to provide.   They have been missing in action as this fiasco unfolds.

They must act now to press for an immediate resolution of the dispute.  They need to obtain ironclad assurances that additional costs will be borne by themselves, not by either federal, state, or local governments or especially by Dulles Toll Road users who are already stuck paying for half the$3 billion project.  They should also make sure that forthcoming fines are applied against the onerous debt laid on Dulles Toll road users over the next four decades. 

If our leaders don’t quickly resolve this situation, the Silver Line may not open until next year and we may pay millions of dollars through added tolls and taxes for the failure of MWAA and Bechtel to meet their contractual obligations.   At worst, MWAA and Bechtel may go to court, putting completion of the project on hold indefinitely. 

Our station is ready.  Where are our Silver Line trains? (Robert Thomson/Washington Post)

Thursday, March 20, 2014

Metro's Silver Line opening indefinitely delayed, WUSA9, March 19, 2014

Colin Mills: RCA Wants Your Thoughts on Baron Cameron Plan, RestonNow, March 20, 2014

Colin Mills/File photoAccording to the Chinese zodiac, 2014 is the “Year of the Horse.”  But in Reston, it seems like it’s shaping up to be the “Year of the Master Plan.”

In February, the Board of Supervisors approved changes to Reston’s Master Plan to allow for mixed-use development around the Silver Line Metro stations.  And now, the County Park Authority is preparing a Master Plan for Baron Cameron Park.

RCA and our Reston 2020 Committee is very interested in what happens at Baron Cameron, particularly in light of the projected athletic field shortage in Reston when the aforementioned mixed-use development is built. But more importantly, we’re interested in hearing what the community has to say.

That’s why Reston 2020 is holding a “ResTown Hall Meeting” on the Baron Cameron plan on April 7. This is your chance to speak out about the proposed changes to Baron Cameron: what you like, what you don’t like, what you think should be added, and what unanswered questions you have.

Baron Cameron Park has a bit of an interesting history.  The site was original owned by Fairfax County Public Schools, which intended to use the site to construct a middle and/or high school for Reston.  In the mid-1970s, with no school yet built on the site, the school system allowed the Fairfax County Park Authority to build and manage some temporary recreation facilities on the site.

Over time, these facilities included athletic fields, a community garden, a playground, and an off-leash dog park.  In 2006, with no school ever having been built on the site, FCPS turned Baron Cameron over to the Board of Supervisors, which in turn transferred it to the Park Authority in 2011.

Historically, no one’s paid that much attention to Baron Cameron.  But interest in the park has increased dramatically in the last year or so.  The news that RCC was considering the park as a possible site for its proposed indoor rec center generated a great deal of public discussion.  More recently, some of the park’s neighbors filed a lawsuit to shut down the dog park due to the noise.

With public attention focused on the park, the Park Authority has come up with a draft Master Plan, which it will formally present at a public meeting on Thursday, March 27 at 7 p.m. at Aldrin Elementary.  The draft plan includes a number of changes to the park: adding artificial turf and lights to the fields, increasing parking, adding a picnic pavilion and restrooms, expanding the community garden, including multi-use courts, and building a trail network that connects to Brown’s Chapel Park next door.

There are also plan alternatives, which would allow construction of an indoor rec center and relocation of the dog area to an interior part of the park.

I encourage everyone to attend the Park Authority’s meeting if you can.  But I also hope you’ll come out to the ResTown Hall Meeting on the April 7 to learn more, make your voice heard, and talk with your neighbors about the plan and what you think.

Our meeting will begin with a recap of what’s in the plan, for those who couldn’t attend the Park Authority’s presentation.  But we’ll also provide additional information.  We’ll attempt to put the proposed changes at Baron Cameron in the larger context of Reston’s coming redevelopment.  We’ll also discuss any issues that were raised by the public at the Park Authority meeting, and fill you in on the research and analysis Reston 2020 has done on the rec center and the athletic field situation in Reston.

But the main purpose of our meeting is to listen to you, Reston’s citizens.  So after providing this background information, we’ll break into small groups to talk in detail about the plan.  Each group will have a chance to talk about the strengths of the Baron Cameron Plan, any concerns about it, suggested additions to the plan, and any questions that might arise.

After the small groups have had the chance to provide their feedback, we’ll report out and try to identify the most important comments, suggestions, and concerns that the community shares about the plan.  Reston 2020 will then take the contributions received at the meeting, consolidate it, and present it to the Park Authority as a community response to the draft Master Plan.

Why is this meeting so important?  Because the proposed changes to Baron Cameron are significant, and time is of the essence.  After the Park Authority’s meeting on the 27th, there is a 30-day window for public comment on the plan.  Once that window is closed, the Park Authority Board will be able to approve the draft plan, and then it will be locked into place.  Once approved, the Master Plan will guide the Park Authority’s vision for the park for the next decade.

So if there are things you think should be added to or removed from the plan, now is the time to speak up.  By consolidating the citizens’ comments and thoughts into a single community response, Reston 2020’s document will speak with a louder and clearer message than a bunch of individual comments.  The document should give the Park Authority something to consider carefully, if the citizens believe that changes are needed.

I look forward to seeing all of you at the ResTown Hall Meeting on April 7.  If you want to learn more about what the Baron Cameron plan means for Reston, or if you want to speak out about anything you want to see preserved or changed in the plan, you’ll never have a better opportunity.  This is your community; make sure that your voice is heard.

Will MWAA sell out the public on the Silver Line?

Near the end of another excellent Washington Post update on the Silver Line construction morass, reporter Lori Aratani drops this sentence:
DTP officials have already hinted that the April deadline may be negotiable, but MWAA probably will face public pressure to not yield.
Also revealed in the article is the fact that MWAA actually approved the installation of the speakers at all the stations that have now been found to not be up to code.
(MWAA Project Manager Pat) Nowakowski said that the station speakers, for example, were approved for installation as part of the project’s design review process and that similar equipment is used in the current Metro system. But state inspectors said they could not approve them for use because they do not meet code requirements.
Do neither MWAA nor Bechtel et al know what state construction codes call for?  How are they allowed to manage or build a multi-billion project if they don't even know the basic rules?  Errors, even incompetence, all around.

Click here to read the rest of this article on the discussion of the Silver Line at MWAA's Board meeting yesterday.

Of course, DTP--Bechtel and it co-conspirators--would like MWAA to give them a break in their failed railway construction effort.  And MWAA is just the organization to do that because it has so little skin in the game--a less than 5% share of construction costs.  Instead, MWAA and its "funding partners"--the Board of Supervisors of Fairfax and Loudoun counties--have shifted over half the cost of construction to Dulles Toll Road users.  That could mean greater increases in tolls than are already anticipated.  

More on continuing Silver Line delays . . ., Fairfax Times, March 19, 2014

With patience wearing thin for many of the Silver Line’s backers, Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority officials said Wednesday that they still cannot provide a date or a timeline for when the new rail line will be completed.
MWAA officials said they are working closely with contractor Dulles Transit Partners and the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority, which will ultimately own and operate the Silver Line, to have the project ready to turn over before April 9. If work continues beyond that date, Dulles Transit Partners could be subject to millions of dollars in penalties under the terms of the contract.
MWAA Board of Directors member Tom Davis, who is also a former congressman from Fairfax County, said he hopes the authority is prepared to pursue legal action against the contractor “to hold their feet to the fire.” . . .
Click here for the rest of this article.  

It is clear that MWAA CEO Jack Potter and other MWAA spokespersons are trying to smooth public concerns about the timely completion of Phase 1 of the Silver Line.  It is equally clear that, as MWAA Board member Tom Davis points out, this is now turning to a long, acrimonious legal fight, not a timely engineering and construction solution.

Don't expect to be riding the Silver Line soon, maybe not even this year as we said before.  And remember, time is money.

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Still no firm word on Silver Line completion, Washington Post, March 19, 2014

Lori Aratani writes in today's Post:
Here’s the latest update on the Silver Line.
To start: No we do not yet know when Silver Line passenger service will begin. And even though the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority’s Board of Directors is slated to get an update on the project’s first phase at their monthly meeting this morning, we are still unlikely to have an answer.
What the board — and the public — will likely be told, is that the contractor on the $5.6 billion rail project — Dulles Transit Partners and MWAA officials are still working to determine what needs to be done in order for the project to be considered “substantially complete.”
For their part, DTP spokeswoman Michelle Michael said Tuesday that they had not yet received a definitive list of the issues MWAA would like them to address in order for the project to be considered complete.
Officials at MWAA said the two sides are trying to work out the outstanding issues.
“We are meeting daily, multiple times a day to get the right people together to get clarification of what needs to be resolved,” said Pat Nowakowski, executive director of the rail project. “We are working as aggressively and as expeditiously as we can to get the project done as soon as possible.”
Neither side would offer a timeline for when the project might be complete. . . .
Click here for the rest of this article.

So, three billion dollars and four years after construction began, the people who built the Silver Line (Bechtel and its DTP co-conspirators) and the people who have mangled the management of that construction (MWAA) still don't agree on what's wrong with the Silver Line's construction, whose responsible, and when it will all be fixed.  Now attorneys--who know nothing about construction but a lot about the law--are playing the lead role.

Lawsuits as well as fines are in the wind. 

And who will likely end up paying for all this?  You guessed it:  Primarily the users of the Dulles Toll Road.  No matter that Bechtel may get fined for each day late it delivers the project beginning in two weeks.  No matter that DTP is supposed to cover any cost overruns.  Still, you know that DTP will just wait out MWAA and its "funding partners".  MWAA will take the fine money and use it somewhere else (unless Rep. Gerry Connolly follows up on our suggestion more than two weeks ago  that the fines be diverted to cover DTR user costs, but no response from him yet) and, since there is virtually no pain for MWAA in the "funding partners" absorbing the extra costs (less than 5% go to MWAA), they have little skin in the game and will willingly accept covering the cost overruns to get the project finished.

From Day One, we have questioned the non-competitive selection of Bechtel and its cronies--masters of the multi-billion dollar cost overrun in Boston's "Big Dig"--as the lead contractor for the Phase 1 Silver Line project.  Since they have nothing to lose after failing to win the lead on Phase 2 of the Silver Line construction effort, they will simply not complete the needed work barring an unexpected early and definitive court decision that they must. 

It is now possible to envision that we may not see the Silver Line completed and operational in 2014 as attorneys for both sides do what they do best, argue and run up billable hours.