Reston Spring

Reston Spring
Reston Spring
Showing posts with label Soapstone Overpass. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Soapstone Overpass. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 23, 2016

Cost of Key Reston Station Area Road Improvement Projects to Double or Triple Board-approved Projections?

Friday, May 16, 2014

Why costs often creep on public-works projects, Washington Post, May 14, 2014

WaPo's Antonio Olivo and Katherine Shaver have written an excellent article on the escalating prices of public works projects that everyone, including state legislators and county supervisors should take to heart.  And the rest of us should remember this article and its lessons every time a new proposal--for a bridge, an indoor tennis facility, an aquatics center, etc..--is offered up that sounds too good to be true.  It almost certainly will be, and you can count on actual construction costs and even operating costs to double these initial estimates.

But let's take a look at what Olivo and Shaver have to say:
What do Metrorail’s Silver Line, the Columbia Pike streetcar in Arlington County and the Intercounty Connector in Maryland have in common?
They have turned out to cost far more than initially projected. And, as often happens in such cases, the public is outraged over the bill.

The script — most recently playing out in Arlington County after officials revealed that the price tag for the streetcar is $100 million more than first estimated — is fairly common.
With fanfare, officials unveil plans for a new subway line, bridge or other infrastructure improvement that, they promise, will make life easier or generate new tax revenue without breaking the budget.
Then, months or years later, they’ll sheepishly admit that the project will stretch the budget a little. And local residents revolt. . . .
To get a project up and running, public officials may lowball a cost estimate at the outset, then ask for forgiveness and patience later, said William Ibbs, a professor of construction management at the University of California at Berkeley who has worked as an adviser on transportation projects worldwide, including Boston’s “Big Dig” highway-tunnel project, which was $12 billion over budget when it was finished nine years behind schedule in 2007.
That’s particularly the case during an economic downturn, when local officials hope to create jobs and contractors are especially eager to get work.
“I’m not saying they’re committing fraud, but let’s say they’re overly optimistic,” Ibbs said about public officials whose initial cost estimates are on the low end of likely. “They’ll get the work going and then the public will be reluctant to cancel a project because they’ve spent all this money so far.” . . .
Once a project gets approval, planners and engineers dive deeper into its feasibility with a more-refined analysis that takes into account planned stops along a transit route or overall soil conditions, said Whit Blanton, an Orlando-based transportation planner. 
Construction delays and increases in a project’s scope can also lead to cost creep, said John D. Porcari, a former Maryland transportation secretary who recently served as deputy U.S. transportation secretary. On a $2.5 billion project, inflation alone can add $60 million to $70 million for each year construction doesn’t occur, he said.
Delays stem most often from permitting problems, changes to a project’s design and shifts in political administrations, when newly arrived public officials want more time to review a project, Porcari said. The costs of major expenses such as labor, construction materials and real estate also are difficult to pin down until much of a project’s design has been completed. . . .
And there is much more.

We believe the line of explanatory analysis done by UC(B) Professor Ibbs above is the primary source of this under-estimating phenomenon.

For the record, let us note these price escalations on planned projects here in Reston:
  • The Soapstone Extension:   The bridge across the Dulles Corridor from Soapstone Drive to Sunset Hills was forceast in the RMAG report in early  2008 included $32MM for the bridge and $10MM for the roadway links for a total of $42MM.  A few weeks ago, the county's feasibility study put the design and construction costs now at $50MM-$60MM.  However, with the necessary land acquisition costs, the total cost of the project has now ballooned to $100MM-$150MM.   We anticipate the cost will reach at least $200MM before construction is completed sometime next decade.
  • The RCC Aquatic Center:  RCC has had its consultant Brailsford & Dunlavey estimate construction (& operating) costs for a new Reston aquatic center on three different occasions with 6 different designs/capabilities, so it is virtually impossible to show a specific total cost escalation from mid-2009 to its latest update in November 2013.  Nonetheless, taking the cost of design and construction (not land) on a gross square feet (GSF) basis, the trend for the earliest options most like the latest November 2013 option show the following:
    Reston Recreation Center Estimated Construction Costs
    2009-2013
In short, there has been a 35% increase in forecast construction costs per square foot over four years--and the project hasn't even reached the engineering feasibility stage yet.  The likely cost (not counting land) could easily double the latest forecast levels with an 85-90 thousand square foot aquatic center cost reach $70-80 million.  The experience of Arlington County with its planned Long Bridge aquatic center, now on hold because of escalating costs, is a cautionary tale.  The forecast cost for the 115,000 GSF facility  in mid-2013 was $62 million ($539 per GSF), a number that shot up to $82 million ($713 per GSF) when the bids came in late last year--and operating costs escalated even more.
All this is a lesson for wary taxpayers and it may be possible that public officials may also learn from this lesson.  We certainly hope so.

Friday, March 14, 2014

Why America (including Fairfax County) stinks at building infrastructure

The Week online newspaper asks the question, "Why is it so expensive to build a bridge in America?"

It also provides the answer in its subtitle, "The answer: Our greedy and undemocratic political culture"

The article compares the pathetically high price and low quality of bridge construction efforts in the United States with those in Europe.  It traces the usually reported causes:
1. Expensive labor. From the top brass at New York's Metropolitan Transportation Authority: "The MTA is required to overstaff projects so that the same [tunnel boring machine] work, for instance, that can be done in Spain with nine workers must be done in [New York City] with 25 workers."
2. Out-of-control private contractors. From Stephen Smith at Bloomberg: "Agencies can't keep their private contractors in check. Starved of funds and expertise for in-house planning, officials contract out the project management and early design concepts to private companies that have little incentive to keep costs down and quality up."
3. A crap procurement process. The classic American way to pay for a big project is to round up about half of the funding (or even less), start construction, and then use a sunk-cost-fallacy to get the rest. This, obviously, is not conducive to efficient or speedy projects. (Looking at you, California high-speed rail.)
But the writer, Ryan Cooper, takes the matter further:
The reality is that when it comes to cost and quality, America is doing basically everything wrong. Again, we're not just a bit behind the curve — we're ridiculously, embarrassingly behind the curve.
The fact that both left- and right-aligned institutions (public employee unions and private contractors, respectively) are implicated here is evidence that this isn't a typical left-right situation. And if we look internationally, both Singapore (very free-markety) and Sweden (unembarrassedly socialist) manage much cheaper building costs than America.
This is basically about our greedy and opaque political culture.
The U.S. is a low-trust society, by developed-world standards, and our infrastructure institutions are usually a complex, stunningly corrupt hodgepodge. It's nearly impossible to get transparently funded projects through our janky political institutions, so instead of doing the slow and patient work of building democratic support for a new project and explicitly voting for the needed spending, which can then be completed without fear of backlash, we try to hide it through "independent" authorities, or the tax code, or duplicitous ballot initiatives.
 Here are a couple of big examples locally:
  • More than $6 billion (and still rising) to build 23 miles of railway and eleven stations for the Silver Line when the forecast in 2004's Final Environmental Impact Statement (REIS) was $3.5 billion.
  • Transportation infrastructure in Tysons for the next 40 years to accommodate the Silver Line mushroomed from a 2010 County estimate of $2.0 billion to $3.0 billion in January 2012 in current dollars and $5.5 billion in inflated dollars (3%/yr).  And (a) that doesn't count interest on capital projects nor (b) has full engineering analyses been completed on any of the many needed projects, which will increase costs further.  
  • The Soapstone Connector, originally projected in 2008 by RMAG to cost $42 million, including associated roadways, is now projected to cost $92 million--and it won't be built until the next decade.
Most worrisome about all of the above is that none of them have been completed and, indeed, only spending on the Silver Line for construction has begun.  The cost of these projects will almost certainly rise substantially.

And one small example:  The County budgeted $500,000 to complete 500' of sidewalk to the south side entrance of the Wiehle Station.  That's $1,000 per foot!   The work is done, but we don't  know the final cost.

Read the full article here. 

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Colin Mills: Soapstone Connector Is Good Work In Progress, RestonNow, March 6, 2014

Colin Mills/File photoSpring and the Silver Line opening both feel a long way away right now. When you’re digging out from the latest snowstorm and reading about MWAA’s declaration that the line isn’t ready for turnover to Metro, it’s hard to convince yourself otherwise.

But believe it or not, we are getting closer to both. In the case of spring, the vernal equinox is on March 20, just a couple weeks away. (The real beginning of spring, baseball’s Opening Day, is a week and a half later.) With the Silver Line, unfortunately, we don’t yet have a firm opening date. But each day that passes brings us closer to both long-awaited events. For now, all we can do is wait.

In the meantime, we can pass the time by preparing for the impacts that the Metro will bring to Reston. The most notable of these is traffic. As RCA has stated repeatedly, new crossings of the Dulles Toll Road are key to easing congestion around the Silver Line stations. And of the proposed new crossings, the Soapstone Connector is the furthest along.

Last month, the County Department of Transportation presented the latest on the Soapstone project to the Hunter Mill Transportation Advisory Committee. RCA Vice President John Hanley attended the meeting, and he gave the Board an update last week. The good news is that the county understands the importance of the project and is moving it along; however, there are a couple of major questions that must be resolved before this important link in Reston’s transportation network can be built.

The last time I wrote about the Soapstone Connector, back in May, the County was evaluating several proposed alignments for the connector. They alignment has now been selected; it’s a hybrid of a couple of the previous options.

And on the whole, it looks pretty good.

On the south side, the connector links up with Soapstone Drive, which is a definite plus.  You might have assumed this was a given, since the project is called the “Soapstone Connector,” but several of the alternatives would not have connected to Soapstone.)  The alignment passes through the existing National Association of Secondary School Principals building and generally follows the western side of Association Drive before crossing the Toll Road.

On the north side, the connector will run to the west of the BAE Systems building and the gas pipeline, and east of Plaza America, before ending at a signalized intersection with Sunset Hills Road. The connector will consist of two lanes over the bridge and three lanes on either side (two travel lanes and a turn lane), as well as bike lanes, a sidewalk, and a shared-use trail. The connector will not provide access to the Toll Road, but it will serve as a relief valve for crosstown traffic and for those trying to access the Wiehle station from the south and west.

This alignment seems like a worthy compromise. It’s a little farther away from the Wiehle station than would be ideal, but it connects directly to Soapstone Drive and requires relatively little disruption of existing properties.  Constructing two lanes over the Toll Road instead of four holds down the overall cost of the project, and the bike lanes and trails encourage pedestrian and bike travel to the station.

Sounds like a plan, right? Well, there are a couple things that still need to be dealt with before the plan can become reality.  The biggest ones are the challenges that face any infrastructure project: time and money.

When will the Soapstone Connector be ready?  We don’t know. Ideally, it would be in place when the Wiehle station opened, to divert some of the traffic from the immediate vicinity of the station. That obviously won’t happen, but will it be ready during the years when Wiehle is the end of the line? Probably not. The project hasn’t even begun preliminary engineering yet; it’s not certain that construction will even occur during this decade.

Part of the reason for that is the issue of funding. The current cost estimate for the project is $92 million, although that’s only a rough guess at this point. Whatever the final cost, it’s certain to be a significant outlay. And so far, the County has allocated only $2.5 million for further planning and study.

Where will the rest of the money come from? In all likelihood, funding will have to come from several sources.  Hopefully, developer proffers will be a piece of the puzzle. But of course, that money wouldn’t be available until redevelopment starts around the stations. And that depends on economic conditions, among other things.

Presumably, the Soapstone Crossing will be a key topic of the “inclusive process” on transportation funding that the Supervisors called for when they approved the revised Comprehensive Plan last month. RCA looks forward to participating in that process. If we’re going to prevent the Toll Road corridor from becoming a barrier that divides our community in half, we must figure out how to pay for the transportation infrastructure we’ll need. This is perhaps the most important implementation question that we face as we prepare for the transformation of the Toll Road corridor, and RCA is ready to be involved in finding the solution.

In the meantime, we find ourselves waiting, just like we’re waiting for spring and the Silver Line. But I am encouraged that the County is making progress on the connector, and that they’ve selected an alignment that makes sense. RCA will continue watching both the Connector and the Silver Line. We’ll keep you informed and keep advocating for solutions that maximize the benefits and minimize the costs to our community.

As for spring… sorry, you’re on your own there.

Colin Mills is the president of Reston Citizens Association. He writes weekly on Reston Now.

Sunday, March 2, 2014

Proposed Soapstone Drive Connector Project, John Hanley, March 1, 2014



1. SCOPE, TIMING AND COST

The Soapstone Drive Connector Project, #15 in the Fairfax County (FC) Revised Recommended Priority Project List, is planned for funding during the period FY 2015-2020. It is intended to provide a crossing for cars, bicycles and pedestrians over the Dulles Toll Road (DTR) between Sunrise Valley Drive and Sunset Hills Road.

The project has received approval for planning level funding and $2.5 million has been allocated for ongoing study and evaluation. Located in Hunter Mill District, the Soapstone Connector (SC) represents a major undertaking and is estimated to cost $92 million. At this early stage, FC believes that this sum will not necessarily represent the eventual CapEx. Several buildings are likely to have to be demolished and depending on redevelopment plans, developers’ proffers may reduce FC’s outlay.

It is unlikely that the SC project, even if the proposed plan is approved soon, will be constructed this decade.  As the County states in its priority listing, its construction will hinge on the availability of further funding and favorable market conditions.

2. ROUTE OF THE PROPOSED CONNECTOR

Fairfax County Department of Transportation (FCDOT) reviewed five different routes from the end of Soapstone over the DTR. In FCDOT’s words, “…none of the alternatives emerged as superior”. Eventually, the Department compromised with a hybrid route. This still has to be approved by the FC Board of Supervisors.

The hybrid route begins directly across from Soapstone, traversing Sunrise Valley via a signal controlled crossing. Its proposed route broadly follows the western side of Association Drive, impacting several properties and buildings, particularly the present HQ of the National Association of Secondary School Principals.

It is anticipated that, that appropriate at grade intersections will be incorporated both to the south and north of the DTR along the connector route, so as to provide access to properties along the route.

Soapstone, as it approaches Sunrise Valley, consists of two active traffic lanes, with a center lane for turning, plus two bicycle lanes. This represents a cost advantage for the actual crossing bridge over the DTR, since it will only need to consist of two lanes (no turns on the bridge), two bicycle lanes and one shared use path. Nevertheless, the bridge crossing will require the construction of significantly high and substantial ramps to support it as it traverses the corridor.

As the connector heads north after crossing the DTR, it enters a clear area, before its route affects several properties prior to its end with a proposed signal controlled junction at Sunset Hills to the west of the BAE complex in front of the electrical transformer installation to the north.

3. CONCLUSION

All in all, the hybrid connector route appears to be a good choice. While it joins Sunset Hills further west than some might like, it does provide a clean intersection at Sunrise Valley Drive (rather than an offset second intersection) and follows a route that minimizes disruption of the present building/property fabric. All of the other alternatives would appear to require the same ramp construction noted above.

March 1, 2014

John Hanley is Vice President of Reston Citizens Association and a member of the Reston 2020 Committee Coordinating Committee. 

For the viewgraphs used in the recent County presentation, please click here.  The specifics of the County's approved transportation capital investment priorities is available here.   
 

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Recommended Soapstone extension route across Dulles Corridor selected

In a presentation at the Hunter Mill Transportation Advisory Committee meeting at 8AM this morning, Fairfax County Transportation staff disclosed the recommended route for the planned connection between Soapstone Drive across the Dulles Corridor to Sunset Hills.  The "hybrid" route will start at the end of Soapstone and proceed northwesterly to Sunset Hills just west of the gas pipeline right-of-way.  No estimate is given for the full cost of the proposed crossover.

Here is the key routing viewgraph from this morning's presentation:

 

Here is the viewgraph describing the next steps in the process:


This is the entire Transportation staff presentation: