Reston Spring

Reston Spring
Reston Spring

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

UPDATED: County library chief proposes more than $900,000 in further cuts to the FCPL budget

UPDATE #2:  In feedback we have received from Deputy County Executive David Molchany, he states that he made the cuts in the County Library budget, which--as we report below--were extremely disproportionate to the size of the Library budget and attributed to Sam Clay and Ed Long.  Apparently, Mr. Clay did not have a "conversation" with Mr. Long, although we never said he did.  More importantly,  it appears that "at no time" did Mr. Clay step forward and say to anyone that the proposed cuts were outrageous and unacceptable or otherwise object to the severity of the proposed cuts.  

Here is what Molchany and Clay say:


From: Molchany, Dave
Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2014 3:00 PM
To: Clay III, Edwin S.
Cc: Strotman, Katie; White-Williams, Patricia; King, Debra; Winkels, Evelyn; Kositch, Margaret R; LIB-BRANCH MANAGERS; LIB-BRANCH MANAGERS ASST; LIB-ADMIN; LIB-ARCHIVES; LIB TechTips; Charles Fegan; Donald Heinrichs; Joseph(Dr.) Sirh (josephsirh@cox.net); Karrie Delaney; Koplitz, margaret; Kristin Cabral; Liz Clements; Mary Petersen (mpetersen3936@gmail.com); Michael Cutrone; Michael Donovan; Priscille Dando; Willard Jasper; Molchany, Dave
Subject: Re: Comments on new cuts to FCPL
Sam was not involved. The $250,000 was new money added in the County Executive's Advertised Budget and now suggested as a reduction and the other cuts were proposed to the Board of Supervisors last year and simply put forward again. 
My message may not get to the Library staff lists for Branch Managers, Branch Managers Assistants, Admin, Archives and Tech Tips... Please make sure that it is forwarded to these groups. 
D
David J. Molchany
Deputy County Executive

Sent from my iPad
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On Mar 19, 2014, at 2:48 PM, "Clay III, Edwin S." <Edwin.Clay@fairfaxcounty.gov> wrote:
Contrary to the information contained in Ms. Kaplan’s memo as well as the ongoing misinformation in the Reston blog, I at no time had a conversation with the County Executive regarding the proposed  budget cuts for the library system.  He may have had conversations with other agency heads re the proposed cuts but I was not one of them.
Sam
Edwin S. Clay III
Director, Fairfax County Public Library
703-324-8308-phone
703-963-6310-cell
703-222-3193-fax
Molchany deserves at least some credit for stepping up and accepting responsibility for this travesty.

UPDATE #1:  Fairfax County Chief Executive Ed Long's proposal for additional cuts to the FY2015 budget includes the library cuts recommended by Library Chief Sam Clay and provides additional details.  

The proposed $250,000 cut in the "materials" budget (found in the IT section of Long's memo):

(would have allowed) for the purchase of nearly 13,000 items in areas such as children’s homework support, additional copies of popular non-fiction, college guides, tests and job skill manuals, and additional copies of classic non-fiction titles.   This increase was intended to be the first of a four year commitment to increase the collections within libraries.
The  proposed $674,359 from the library’s budget that would eliminate 14/7 FTE merit positions:
. . . would reduce hours by 9-hours-per-week at Regional Libraries (Note:  this includes Reston Regional Library) and 6-hours-per week at Community Libraries, with a corresponding reduction of 14/7.0 FTE merit positions and 14 benefits-eligible exempt positions. This reduction would cause substantial customer dissatisfaction given the fact that hours were just restored in FY 2013 and would be strongly opposed by the Library Board. If additional reductions beyond the FY 2012 operating hours were requested, the Library would seek to adjust hours in a similar across-the-board manner.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

From: Clay III, Edwin S.
Sent: Tuesday, March 18, 2014 5:05 PM
To: 'Charles Fegan'; 'Donald Heinrichs'; Joseph(Dr.) Sirh (josephsirh@cox.net); 'Karrie Delaney'; 'Koplitz, margaret'; 'Kristin Cabral'; Liz Clements; Mary Petersen (mpetersen3936@gmail.com); 'Michael Cutrone'; 'Michael Donovan'; 'Priscille Dando'; 'Willard Jasper'
Cc: LIBRARY; 'Barbara Leadbetter'; 'Brian Jacoby'; 'Bruce Wallachy'; 'Christine Peterson'; 'Corinne Savage'; 'George Mason Friends'; 'Gerald Miske'; 'John Ball'; 'John Brugger'; 'John Finneman'; 'Karen O’Meara'; 'Lois Leinkram'; 'Michael Eaton'; 'Michelle Miller'; 'Nora Gyuk'; 'Patricia Jack'; 'Patricia Riedinger'; 'Paul Herer'; 'Peter Bastone'; 'Phylis Salak'; 'Rebecca Fleck'; 'Sharon Kraftchak'; 'Steven May'; 'Yolanda Atkins'; 'AS'; 'Courtney Bulger'; 'Donald Britton'; 'Duwain Ketch'; Gordon, Gerald L.; 'Gretchen Moss'; 'J.D. Morrissette'; 'James Dyke'; 'Janet Kerr Tener'; 'Jeffrey Armstrong'; 'Joan Kane'; 'Judi Nardella'; 'Laura Mandeles'; 'Leah Fried'; 'Louise Meade'; 'Lucinda Robb'; 'Mark Snow'; Murphy, Martina M.; 'Mary Myers'; 'Mary Zimmerman'; 'Patrick Dexter'; 'Paula Koeck-gomez'; 'Rebecca Parker'; 'Richard Brady'; 'Robin Thurman'; 'Sally Merten'; 'Susan Harman'; 'Sushma Shenoy'; 'Whit Minkler'
Subject: Possible cuts to the library budget

 

Good afternoon:


In response to a motion from Supervisor Cook (see pages 8 and 9) at the March 4 Board of Supervisors meeting, the county executive presented the Board of Supervisors with a reduction package today at the first budget committee meeting. This list, prepared by the county executive, included the following items effecting the library:

  • Remove the $250,000 increase for materials from the library’s FY2015 budget;
  • Eliminate an additional $674,359 from the library’s budget and eliminate 14/7 FTE merit positions. This amount was provided in FY2013 to increase hours at community branches by 6 hours per week and regionals by 9 hours per week. (This reduction to the budget would mean library hours and staffing would be reduced to FY2012 levels.)
  • No further reductions in employee compensation: The county executive discouraged the Board of Supervisors from considering an employee compensation increase of 2 percent for FY 2015, but suggests the increase remain at 1.29 percent for FY2015 and an additional two percent increase in FY2016 for a total 3.29 percent compensation increase over the two year period.

I will send a link to the full reduction list once it is posted to the county’s public website.


Keep in mind these reductions are a proposal--there are still public hearings and community meetings to be held. Chairman Bulova outlined her priorities for this year’s budget process:  the impact of the tax rate on the taxpayer; the requirements for schools and then the county.


The Board of Supervisors will make modifications, i.e., mark-up the budget on Tuesday, April 22 and adopt the budget on Tuesday, April 29.  Action on these items will take place at one of those two meetings. I will keep you apprised of any additional information going forward.
Sam
The specific motion by Supervisor Cook mentioned above is as follows:
Following further discussion (of a motion to find further funding cuts to meet claimed shortfalls in FCPS budget needs), Supervisor Cook moved to amend the motion to direct the County Executive to identify $15–20 million in County spending reductions to go on a Consideration list. Supervisor Herrity seconded the motion. 
And we know that the County Executive Ed Long wouldn't know how to put together or amend the library budget.  

Long almost certainly told Clay to propose further specific cuts.  The result was the above proposal by Sam Clay to cut more than $900,000 from the advertised FY2015 FCPL operating budget proposal--accounting for some 15-20% of the proposed entire County-wide package.  This proposed $900,000+ cut is from a $27.7 million operating budget proposal that is already down more than $1 million from FY2014's revised budget and comprises less than three-quarters of one percent of the proposed $3.7 BILLION in proposed General Fund spending the County expects FY2015.  Indeed, the County's total proposed spending for FY2015 is twice that, $7.0 BILLION!


. . . but Long and Clay have to cut the library budget MORE!


The unmitigated disaster that is the "leadership" by Sam Clay of the County's library system has no limits.   At what point does one say to the County Executive or even a Supervisor, "Enough is enough!"  Apparently Clay lacks that courage and commitment to the County's public libraries.  Long clearly doesn't care.

If Clay were honorable, he would quit.  Since he isn't, he should be fired.  And it would really help if Long followed him right out the door.  

Friday, March 14, 2014

Why America (including Fairfax County) stinks at building infrastructure

The Week online newspaper asks the question, "Why is it so expensive to build a bridge in America?"

It also provides the answer in its subtitle, "The answer: Our greedy and undemocratic political culture"

The article compares the pathetically high price and low quality of bridge construction efforts in the United States with those in Europe.  It traces the usually reported causes:
1. Expensive labor. From the top brass at New York's Metropolitan Transportation Authority: "The MTA is required to overstaff projects so that the same [tunnel boring machine] work, for instance, that can be done in Spain with nine workers must be done in [New York City] with 25 workers."
2. Out-of-control private contractors. From Stephen Smith at Bloomberg: "Agencies can't keep their private contractors in check. Starved of funds and expertise for in-house planning, officials contract out the project management and early design concepts to private companies that have little incentive to keep costs down and quality up."
3. A crap procurement process. The classic American way to pay for a big project is to round up about half of the funding (or even less), start construction, and then use a sunk-cost-fallacy to get the rest. This, obviously, is not conducive to efficient or speedy projects. (Looking at you, California high-speed rail.)
But the writer, Ryan Cooper, takes the matter further:
The reality is that when it comes to cost and quality, America is doing basically everything wrong. Again, we're not just a bit behind the curve — we're ridiculously, embarrassingly behind the curve.
The fact that both left- and right-aligned institutions (public employee unions and private contractors, respectively) are implicated here is evidence that this isn't a typical left-right situation. And if we look internationally, both Singapore (very free-markety) and Sweden (unembarrassedly socialist) manage much cheaper building costs than America.
This is basically about our greedy and opaque political culture.
The U.S. is a low-trust society, by developed-world standards, and our infrastructure institutions are usually a complex, stunningly corrupt hodgepodge. It's nearly impossible to get transparently funded projects through our janky political institutions, so instead of doing the slow and patient work of building democratic support for a new project and explicitly voting for the needed spending, which can then be completed without fear of backlash, we try to hide it through "independent" authorities, or the tax code, or duplicitous ballot initiatives.
 Here are a couple of big examples locally:
  • More than $6 billion (and still rising) to build 23 miles of railway and eleven stations for the Silver Line when the forecast in 2004's Final Environmental Impact Statement (REIS) was $3.5 billion.
  • Transportation infrastructure in Tysons for the next 40 years to accommodate the Silver Line mushroomed from a 2010 County estimate of $2.0 billion to $3.0 billion in January 2012 in current dollars and $5.5 billion in inflated dollars (3%/yr).  And (a) that doesn't count interest on capital projects nor (b) has full engineering analyses been completed on any of the many needed projects, which will increase costs further.  
  • The Soapstone Connector, originally projected in 2008 by RMAG to cost $42 million, including associated roadways, is now projected to cost $92 million--and it won't be built until the next decade.
Most worrisome about all of the above is that none of them have been completed and, indeed, only spending on the Silver Line for construction has begun.  The cost of these projects will almost certainly rise substantially.

And one small example:  The County budgeted $500,000 to complete 500' of sidewalk to the south side entrance of the Wiehle Station.  That's $1,000 per foot!   The work is done, but we don't  know the final cost.

Read the full article here. 

Only one Reston neighborhood makes the top 1,000 wealthiest in the US...and that's a good thing!

Yes, folks, we have a winner:  Brandermill-Hunters End. The neighborhood is located northwest of the intersection of Wiehle and Baron Cameron avenues out to Rt. 7. 

Brandermill-Hunters End ranks #665 among the top 1,000 wealthiest neighborhoods in the country and #15 among the 28 qualifying wealthiest neighborhoods in the Washington, DC's Virginia suburbs according to The 2010 Higley 1000. (The metro WDC area has a total of 68 wealthy neighborhoods on the list.)


Brandermill-Hunters End Neighborhood, Reston, VA
While it is unclear why one would put together such a compilation (despite its value to those who are marketing condos in Boca or Bentleys in Bethesda), the methodology for making these rankings is impeccably thorough:  
My data is derived from the American Community Survey 2006-2010. My methodology consisted of aggregating contiguous block groups with a mean income over $200,000. Block groups are subdivisions of Census tracts. The whole country is covered by these geographical tracts. A typical Census tract will have 5,000 residents and be made up of 5 block groups of 1,000 residents each. Theoretically, the boundaries should be drawn to group people of similar socio-economic status. The boundaries are meant to stay the same from Census to Census to be able to study the change in neighborhood characteristics over time. A small change in boundaries, particularly if apartments, condominiums are included, can cause a neighborhoods income to plummet.
. . . and we wouldn't want any of those pesky apartments, condos, or even townhomes to sully such a ranking.  Still, one needs only to look at the million dollar-plus condos being planned and built in Tysons and Reston Town Center to see that, yes, you can be wealthy and live in a condo.  

On a broader basis, Dr. Stephen Higley, Professor Emeritus of Urban Geography, University of Montevallo, Montevallo, Alabama, analyzes the ethnic and racial composition of these neighborhoods nationally and by neighborhood.  The results are about what you'd expect:  The wealthiest neighborhoods are far more Non-Hispanic White than the nation generally. This is reflected in the chart below which shows the percentage of minorities in different categories (although the title is misleading).


Barchart showing summary by Race over all subgroups.

FWIW, the Brandermill-Hunters End neighborhood has a mean household income of $212,304 (which isn't really too "mean" at all!) and was 1.6% Black, 6.8% Asian, 3.5% Hispanic and 88.1% Non-Hispanic White in this 2010 review.  

Being an emeritus professor, Dr. Higley has chosen to move from Alabama to Arizona--and he doesn't mince words about his reasons. 
After a 17 year run, I recently retired and moved to Tucson, Arizona. I am now a happy homeowner in the Dorado Country Club in East Tucson. Free at Last!, Free at Last! I managed to get out of Alabama before I died, lol!
Montevallo was so atypical of Alabama: intellectual and liberal in it’s heart as a result of the University’s presence. I miss my good friends from Alabama but I am so happy to leave behind a state that at it’s heart is still a racist, heartless hotbed of anti-intellectual hypocrites. What a dump.
There you go.  BTW, the Dorado Country Club is NOT on Dr. Higley's list. Maybe he should have moved to Reston!  

All kidding aside, the fact that there is one--and only one--of the nation's wealthiest neighborhoods in Reston speaks, in part, to the great value this community places on one its original planning principles:  Providing housing for all incomes and all ages.  The diversity of Reston--wealth, race, ethnicity, religious, age, and more--is one of its greatest assets.  

Thursday, March 13, 2014

Library seeks additional funding from Fairfax Board of Supervisors, Fairfax Times, March 13, 2014

Money would go to staff training, techonology upgrades

Library officials will be asking the Board of Supervisors for additional funding to meet agency needs as part of this year’s budget debate.
The Fairfax County Public Library Board of Trustees voted Wednesday night to request an additional $1 million that would be used for youth service, staff training and technology upgrades.
The board had previously submitted a request for a $1 million increase in its budget for books and other material, aimed at restoring some of the reductions made in leaner budget years.
As the county recovered from the recession, the library cut hours, reduced staff and reduced spending on new materials to save money.
The library administration drew heat from patrons last year when it proposed beta testing a new staffing model aimed at maintaining current hours and services with fewer people in order to reduce operating expenses. . . .
Read the rest of the article here.  

"Heat" is not the word.  "Outrage" or "disgust" are much more appropriate.

. . . And yet the County's advertised budget proposes further cuts in spending for next year, some 40 vacant positions haven't been filled, and the toll of lost books has risen to 460,000-plus.

What is wrong with the County administration and Board of Supervisors???

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Reflections on Kathy Kaplan's Citizen of the Year Ceremony, Colin Mills, March 12, 2014

When RCA revived the Citizen of the Year award in 2008, we intended to spotlight the terrific work done by community volunteers who too often go unrecognized.  This year’s selection, Kathy Kaplan, definitely falls in that tradition.  I was pleasantly surprised by the number of people who complimented me on our choice.  I told them that Kathy deserves the credit; she’s the one who’s been working for the community for decades.  But nonetheless, I was glad to give Kathy some well-deserved accolades at our ceremony Monday night.


Kathy reminds me of our 2011 Citizen of the Year, Nick Brown.  Both are modest folks who prefer to work behind the scenes, avoiding the spotlight.  I was glad we turned the spotlight on Nick then, just as I’m glad we gave Kathy recognition this time around.


In my opening remarks, I noted that Kathy shows what individual citizens can accomplish through hard work and a dedication to the community’s best interests.  If it hadn’t been for her love of libraries and her willingness to pore through long and complicated government documents, we might never have heard of the Beta Plan, the book culling, or the budget cuts to our County library system.  It’s easy to believe that individuals are powerless against big institutions; Kathy showed that it’s not true.
RCA’s Terry Maynard, who nominated Kathy for the award, began with an excerpt from a letter Kathy wrote last summer, discussing a book of poetry she found at the library and expressing her fear that it would be thrown away, like thousands of other County library books in recent years.  For Kathy, the fate of our libraries isn’t an abstract concern; it’s personal.
Terry then walked the audience through all that Kathy did, from reading thousands of pages about the County’s library plans, to writing letters to County officials opposing the library cuts, to reaching out to librarians and library friends groups, to meeting with County supervisors, to gathering over 2,000 signatures on an online petition calling for the library system to re-evaluate its Strategic Plan. 
Clearly, it took a lot of people coming together to convince the Library Board and the Board of Supervisors to stop the Beta Plan and the destruction of books.  But as Terry’s speech made clear, there may be no single person who did more than Kathy Kaplan.
Kathy’s library efforts were the focus of the ceremony, but she has contributed much more to Reston than that.  The next two speakers celebrated some of Kathy’s other good works in the community.


ARCH President Jerry Volloy gave a very emotional speech about Kathy’s contribution to the 9/11 memorial at Brown’s Chapel Park.  He described how, as RA CEO, he led an effort to create a memorial to that awful day (2 Restonians lost their lives in the attacks).  He explained that they created a row of trees and bushes to create a memorial garden, and how the bronze plaques sculpted by Kathy provided the perfect complement to the natural beauty on display.  He noted that one of the plaques included an image of a caterpillar and a butterfly, to symbolize the renewal of life.  Kathy is an artist as well as an activist, and Jerry’s tribute was a fitting celebration of that side of her.

After Jerry spoke, up stepped Connie Hartke, who is on the boards of both RCA and Rescue Reston, the group fighting to save the Reston National Golf Course.  Connie described how nervous she was when she first became active with Rescue Reston a year ago, because she wasn’t up to speed on community issues.  Kathy helped her get informed, and provided invaluable research and information to Rescue Reston.  Connie noted that two of the community’s most valuable assets are the Freedom of Information Act and Kathy, who knows how to use it.


RCA’s Tammi Petrine spoke next; she noted that not only does Kathy read those long and boring documents most of us can’t be bothered with – she understands them!  A valuable skill indeed.  Tammi updated the audience on the ongoing threats to the library system, including a resumption of the book culling and further budget cuts.  She urged everyone to stay involved and continue to support our libraries and our librarians.


When Kathy spoke, she emphasized the importance of libraries in her life.  She grew up in a town where the nearest library was 10 miles away, and she walked there if she had to in order to get her fill of books.  (She described “The Summer of L. Frank Baum,” when she read all the Oz books.  When she moved to Reston in 1983, she treasured our library; even though it was tiny, she took home a giant stack of books every time she went.
Kathy noted that the real heroes of last year are the librarians, some of whom were in attendance to celebrate her award.  She praised them for having the courage to stand up and comment at meetings, and to write letters in their own names, even at the risk of retribution.  She herself, she said, just “caused as much trouble as possible.”

Those of us who know Kathy know how good she is at causing trouble.  And thank goodness for that; a healthy community needs citizens who aren’t afraid to make noise.  We need the Kathy Kaplans of the world, people who are willing to slog through official records and speak out when they see something wrong.  Engaged citizens like Kathy keep our officials honest, and make sure that our institutions keep the best interests of the people at heart.

Thanks to Terry for a thoughtful nomination.  Thanks as always to Leila Gordon and RCC for hosting the event and displaying the award plaque.  And a special thanks to the Harris Teeter over at the Spectrum and Wegman’s in Fairfax for their contributions to the food for our reception.  And congratulations to Kathy Kaplan, a quiet woman who knows how to make noise, and who might just have saved our library system.

2013 RCA Citizen of the Year Kathy Kaplan with RCA Board members (from left)
Terry Maynard, Yavuz Inanli, George Kain, Colin Mills, Tammi Petrine, and Connie Hartke

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

RCA Award Ceremony Comments Recognizing Kathy W. Kaplan as Reston Citizen of the Year for 2013, March 10, 2014, Terry Maynard



. . . Who doesn’t remember, “By the shores of Gitche Gumme, / By the shining Big-Sea-Water, / Stood the wigwam of Nokomis, / Daughter of the Moon, Nokomis.”

I found Susan Jeffers’ illustrated Hiawatha at Reston Regional in with the other children’s poetry.  Much of that collection has been culled, sold away, or burned.  Now that my granddaughter knows from reading this edition of Longfellow that there are many more poems in the original Hiawatha, she wants to hear them all.  Luckily, I have a copy of the entire epic poem.

But this little book, the one we read at bedtime last week, I worry about.  When I take it back to the library will some wet-behind-the ears library page pull it for disposal because it’s old?  Inside the book it says it was published in 1908.  Library Director Sam Clay is having library pages pull old books.  Under the Beta Plan, a front-line librarian will not see this book again before it goes to the dumpster. Will the kid know that this is a recent printing?  Will the kid ever have heard of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow?   Will there ever be another child who reads these words from this very book, “Listen my children, and you shall hear / Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere.”

I cannot bring myself to take it back to the library.  The fate of this one book is important to me.  It should be important to you. . . .

Those words written in a letter last August by our 2013 Reston Citizen of the Year, Kathy Kaplan, capture her passion for our library books, especially poetry and books for children. 

Kathy translated that passion into action that led to changes in the fate of the County’s public libraries.  So it was with great pleasure, honor, and admiration that I nominated Kathy to be RCA’s 2013 Reston Citizen of the Year for her exceptional efforts to stop a Fairfax County Public Library Strategic Plan to downgrade its libraries in the name of organizational efficiency.  As one of two “guinea pigs” for this strategic plan, Reston Regional Library was ground zero for this planned degradation. 

The key features of the ill-considered County library strategic plan included:

  • Reducing the library budget by a third over the last six years;
  • Culling books throughout the system, some 400,000 of which have already been destroyed;
  • Drastically reducing the library staff, including plans to reduce the Reston staff by one-third;
  • De-professionalizing  library staff requirements by replacing certified librarians with “customer service specialists” who would not need to be knowledgeable of library science; and
  • Eliminating Youth Services—children’s librarians and collections—throughout the library system.

Without Kathy’s leadership, unswerving dedication, and perseverance, the County’s libraries would likely still be on a downward spiral with our Reston Regional Library as one of two “guinea pigs” in that effort.  Her extraordinary efforts were singularly consistent with Reston’s goal of providing a high quality of life for people of all backgrounds and was, in fact, the inspiration for an August 2013 RCA Board of Directors resolution calling on the Board of Supervisors to abandon its wrong-headed library strategic plan. 

Among her activities beginning last summer:

  • She identified and worked with County librarians and other library friends deeply concerned about the County strategic plan;
  • She conducted extensive research on the County library’s plan and activities, including acquiring thousands of pages of papers through FOIA that documented the destruction of more than 400,000 books in recent years and other library plan activities and intentions;
  • She met with and wrote letters and e-mails to County senior staff and elected officials, community organizations, and media noting the ongoing and planned decimation of our libraries;
  • She encouraged residents to sign an online petition calling for the Library’s Trustees to stop and re-evaluate the Strategic Plan, a petition that ultimately garnered more than 2,000 signatures;
  • She acquired and shared photographs of the books thrown in a central library operations dumpster that led County Board Supervisor Patty Smyth to personally visit the site, bring back several current books in good condition, and direct senior County officials to stop destroying books; and
  • At the request of the Fairfax County Federation of Citizens Associations Board, she drafted a report on the library Strategic Plan that detailed its intentions and impacts.
As a result of her efforts and the efforts of those she worked with, the Library Board of Trustees recommended and the County Board of Supervisors approved on November 18, 2013, a resolution “to eliminate the process that led to the trashing of hundreds of thousands of books and also throw out a controversial plan to reduce the number of librarians and children’s services in county branches,” as reported by the Washington Post.

We all recognize the effort to rehabilitate our County libraries is far from over, indeed, the County is proposing further budget cuts for our libraries, but at least the worst of the hemorrhaging of books, budgets, and staff has been stopped for the time being.  We all have Kathy Kaplan and her compatriots to thank for this excellent effort.  And we know that Kathy and others will continue their extraordinary efforts to rehabilitate our once excellent library system into one that will serve us, our children, and even our grandchildren for decades to come. 

Thank you, Kathy.  You have more than earned our gratitude and recognition for your exceptional personal efforts in saving our libraries.

Friday, March 7, 2014

One expert's opinion: How the Washington area has flubbed transportation for 50 years, Washington Business Journal, March 7, 2014

Michael Neibauer, WBJ, writes an excellent article on a paper just published by John McClain of GMU's Center for Regional Analysis on the history of transportation development failure in the Washington.  The article provides a variety of details from the paper.  Here are some of them (with our emphasis added):
There was a time, a half-century ago, when the Washington area was on the road to developing a well-conceived system of highways and transit to serve its burgeoning population. But a failure of regional leaders to implement and fund those plans drove us to where we are today: Muddling along.
So says John McClain, a regional planning expert who has served in various policy roles for more than 30 years, with the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments, the Greater Washington Board of Trade and George Mason University's Center for Regional Analysis.
McClain has penned an interesting paper for GMU, which he calls "Reflections on the National Capital Region: Transportation for the Past Half-Century." In it, McClain details transportation planning efforts since the 1950s, and the efforts that local, regional and federal leaders have made to see them through.
His conclusion: Between a lack of leadership, a lack of dedicated funding sources and a lack of a regional authority to drive progress, we're stuck in the mud. . .
"So in looking back over the past half-century at the region's transportation process development and evolution, there are serious doubts about the region's ability to address and resolve its needs in the most effective way," he continues. "It seems it will more or less muddle along — developing reasonably good plans but no really good way to get them done." . .
"One conclusion from the past perspective is that we have not been deficient in developing good plans," McClain writes. "The region has done pretty good regional planning. The failure has been in acting on, funding, and implementing what has been planned."
Nothing much here that those following transportation issues reasonably closely haven't observed and often commented about, but it really helps when someone who has been in the business for decades takes the time to lay out the case in clear black and white for all to see.   Moreover, the condition McClain comments on directly affects the land use planning and its implementation that we in Reston and Tysons have been working on for years because a robust transportation infrastructure--roads, transit, bikes & pedestrian access, and TDM--are all vital to successful implementation of urban development, especially TOD. 

One reason the problem has been particularly acute in Northern Virginia is that the local governments are largely unable--in McClain's phraseology--to act on, fund, and implement their own transportation plans.  Richmond--the General Assembly, VDOT, and VDRPT--keeps a close hold on transportation decisionmaking and funding, leaving local governments, including Fairfax County, only the opportunity to request, implore, and even whine for crucial transportation funding.  To make matters worse, Richmond has created independent bureaucratic entities, such as the NVRTA, that tend to have operational control of key funding and answer to virtually no one, including Richmond.  

It's a wonder we don't have to ford more streams on our roadways in NoVa.  Those of us who have lived in Reston long enough remember doing that regularly on Lawyers Road long before there as any auto access to the Dulles Corridor.  

Please read the rest of the WBJ article here.